M J AKBAR
 


MJ Biography | Siege within column | MJ Voice on the Web | Praise for Books |  Letters to MJ | MJ Photo Gallery | MJ Quotes

BYLINES BY M J AKBAR

Sudden Death and Gradual Justice
BY M J AKBAR
July 24, 2010

It would be odd, and wholly unacceptable, if secularism were to be defined by the fate of a gangster in Gujarat. At stake in the Sohrabuddin Sheikh case is not the religion of the individual, or his preferred means of sustenance [in this case, crime], but the rule of law. It was in pursuit of this principle that the Supreme Court handed over investigation of his death in a fake encounter, and the subsequent murder of Sohrabuddin’s wife Kauserbi, to the CBI on 13 January 2010. The Gujarat government effectively lost its credibility when it admitted in December 2006 that Sohrabuddin had been killed in a fake encounter on 26 November 2005 and that his wife had been murdered two days later.

The Supreme Court has taken a stand that should terrify not just the Gujarat government, but any administration. It has asserted that it is the court’s business to determine guilt and innocence, and not that of the police. The truth is that for at least two decades, and in some places for longer than that, security forces have used fake encounters as the easy option in their war against crime and anti-national terrorism. This is not unique to Gujarat.

We do not know how many innocents have been killed in Mumbai in the process of tackling the renowned underworld of the city. Police officers who shot first and refused to answer questions later have been glamorized as heroes, not only by the Maharashtra government but also by Bollywood.

Bollywood intervened only because this practice has the support of many citizens, for reasons that might not be palatable to either the police or the people. We no longer believe that crime, let alone anti-national terrorism, can be controlled through legitimate means, because corruption has made large parts of the police-judiciary system impotent. Now comes the difficult part: we citizens are partners in crime as well, since we buy products that the underworld sells. Every user of drugs and narcotics in Mumbai is complicit in corruption, because the underworld would not survive without this trade. Rich Mumbaikars who need a hashish puff to keep cool during their fancy parties might want to think before they smoke. Our selfish self wants a level of crime which sustains our weakness, and the elimination of criminals who threaten our comfort.

Amit Shah cannot escape, no matter how smart a politician he might be. The wheels of Indian justice may take their time, but when they move they grind with persistence. Shah will attempt to exploit contradictions in the public mind, for there will be those who support “killer-solutions”, but his case is badly tarred by the accusation that he took money from businessmen in the larger transactions surrounding this case. Shah, and Narendra Modi, will learn that the circumference of power is wider than the political world. This episode will also interfere with Modi’s hopes of becoming his party’s candidate for Prime Minister, which may not displease everyone in his party.

But surely accountability cannot be limited to just one case in one state. Who is responsible for the death of Rajkumar Cherukuri Azad, the 55-year-old Naxalite leader who was shot dead by the Andhra police in Adilabad district? Was this an ‘encounter’ or a ‘fake encounter’? Do the police have evidence of a Naxal attack, to which they were responding? Or did they track Azad on orders from Delhi or Hyderabad, and then murder him?

There is a political dimension to Azad’s death, for he was the prospective bridge between government and the Naxalite movement for any negotiations. Did Delhi want him eliminated because the home ministry had decided that it would kill its way through the Naxal upsurge, and its offer of talks was not serious? Intermediaries like Swami Agnivesh have suggested as much. Is this the moment when Swami Agnivesh should move a writ petition in the Supreme Court, arguing that the Andhra police, being complicit in the death, will make no effort to try and answer these questions?

It is perhaps easier to pose questions than to find answers since we are dealing with a prickly proposition: who is an enemy of state? There is no confusion about a Kasab and the many thousands who have been sent across an international border to damage our country. The problem gets more opaque for the Supreme Court when categories change. The court has taken a courageous decision in ruling that a man like Sohrabuddin, who has killed gangsters to spread an extortion racket and has employees armed with automatic firearms, cannot face an arbitrary death squad. Does Azad, in the opinion of the court, deserve to be killed without a trial because certain persons in Andhra Pradesh and Delhi have decided that this is how it should be?

The Supreme Court is not a political party. It cannot vary its principles to suit pragmatic needs

Post comments to Permalink: Sudden Death and Gradual Justice


C

Bhopal Tragedy: Photo Essay pdf - 1 | Bhopal Tragedy Photo Essay pdf - 2
 

Bookmark and Share


Only 960 years left for Bhutto's war

The Bhuttos, and Bhutto-led governments, seem lost in a rut that has become brittle and boring through over-use. Their only measure of Pakistani patriotism is the level of hysteria that they can simulate against India. A psychiatrist would be tempted to trace this habit to the fate of Sir Shahnawaz Bhutto, Prime Minister of Junagadh before partition, whose plan to merge his state into Pakistan went badly awry. Bhutto went, of course, minus his state, closely followed by the Nawab of Junagadh who left his family behind but escaped with his dogs. Such speculation, however, is not quite within the realm of a newspaper column.

Permalink:  Only 960 years left for Bhutto's war

Subscribe Feeds


READ SUNDAY GUARDIAN (one page): May 16, 2010
READ SUNDAY GUARDIAN (one page): MAY 2, 2010  

BYLINES 2010: Recent Posts

February - April
Sudden Death and Gradual Justice
Only 960 years left for Bhutto's war
Is the middle smoother than a muddle?
A long ride on a wagon of words
Stretch of Imagination is not a description of Peace!
Is Peace on sale in Bhopal?
Above the anger of Bhopal, the Silence of Delhi
The many colors of Red
My brother's peacekeeper
The Crash of expectations
The Comfort and Dangers of Sin and Stupidity
How much sleaze can you spare, brother?
A cut in Delhi, a run in Ranchi
A fairy tale, minus happy ending
100 years after Gokhale, Jinnah
Senapati's route to heroism
Beware a Comedy of Mirrors
Politicians don't get stiff necks
Little Pakistan's big India Problem
Danger Ahead: From aam aadmi to Khaas Aurat?
The gap between promise and delivery
Count the numbers when the numbers...
The PM's high-wire politics
The boys of Chidambaram
Licence to drive, everywhere
January
Peace means the summer of 1965
Price of Power
Smoke and Smokescreens
Peace is where the media is
Sense and absence
Byline Archives : 2009

January
February
March

April
May
June
July

August
September

October
November
December

BYLINES 2008
December
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
April
March
February
January
FROM SEPTEMBER 2004-2007
click Archive
SIEGE WITHIN
[Times of India Column by M J Akbar ]
Siege within

Members of this Blog
M J AKBAR - ILAXI 


Add this image to your Blog/site and link to www.mjakbar.org
DELHI'S ONLY SUNDAY NEWSPAPER
Published simultaneously in Delhi and London


40 pages | Rs. 3/- To get a copy, Ask News Agent or sms <TSG> to 56070
SUBSCRIBE SG (Subscription Form): send post/ courier to The Sunday Guardian, 261, Okhla Industrial Estate, Phase III, New Delhi.

 

 
  MJ IN DIFFERENT MOODS (PHOTO GALLERY)
 

Photo gallery

 BOOK RECOMMENDATIONS

Book Recommendations
 

 

Join Columnists & MJ FANS
Add to Wall Posts | Debate | Discuss


View Ilaxi Patel's profile on LinkedInJoin  LinkedIn Groups Discussion Board
Join LinkedIn Covert Group

eBylines | Feed Reads

Subscribe to MJ Akbar's Bylines

 

 

 

 
Copyright © MJAkbar 2010 - All rights reserved. |  MJ Biography | Home  

Post your comments on Bylines Posts or Send your Email comments, concerns or book recommendations. Anything you wish to communicate to MJ Akbar.  He doesn't always have the opportunity to reply to everything, but he certainly reads it all! 
(E-mails Without Attachments, please!)
M J Akbar
 E-MAIL: mjakbar@mjakbar.org / ilaxi@mjakbar.org
Did you like this Blog of MJ Akbar? Send me your comments, suggestions, etc. Bouquets or Brickbats please:-)

 

M.J. AKBAR'S BLOG : Edited & Brought to You By Ilaxi Patel 
(VA & Official Blogger to MJ)
Editor, Kidsfreesouls.com - Newspaper for Kids with Resources for Parents & Teachers

Started on September 28, 2004. We are Thankful to our Readers, supporters and well wishers
Best viewed in 1024 by 768 Screen Resolution