January 03, 2009
|
The Kautilya Perspective
Right Ideology, wrong
place
By U. Mahesh Prabhu
|
‘It’s neither the
horse nor the elephant and never – e’er – the tiger. It’s the goat
that is offered in sacrifice, even the gods slain the weak.’ said the
legendary Indian diplomat and author of Arthashastra – Kautilya.
We often call ours as
the ‘land of Mahatma’. ‘We are a peace loving nation’ we proudly
declare, furthering ‘and we are proud of it!’ True, absolutely, we
love peace. But more than often we forget that there is a price to be
paid for peace. Peace is not free.
A weak person, no
matter in which part of the world, is bound to be subdued by the
strong men. He gets no respect from men with brawns. ‘Strength
respects strength’, as said by India’s former President Dr. APJ Abdul
Kalam, holds well, always – beyond all incertitude.
Weak has neither the
present nor future. Even if he says that ‘I fight none’ and that ‘I am
all for peace.’ people are certain to mock at him. Why? Because they
know that he can seldom offer a resistance when assailed by a mighty
adversary. Nowhere in the world has a weak been able to live with
respect. Very similar is the case with a weak nation.
But what makes a
human or a nation weak? It’s all about courage. If men lack courage
they are sure to be weak and the country is weak when its
establishment is spineless. Yes, people too have their share of
responsibility, for it is they who vote a government to power.
In India, since the
time of independence we have took a great pride in our Gandhian
Heritage. Our first prime minister though absolutely failed in
carrying forward the ideas of Mahatma in terms of national
development; in his diplomatic speeches across the world he seldom
pretermitted to cite a line, or two, of Mahatma. His was the concept
of economy which was in sharp with Gandhian one. But when it came to
diplomacy and international affairs Nehru was a true Gandhian - as
honest as a monk!
Gandhi may well have
been a great man, but he was seldom a sound politician. His legacy is
replete with blunders in politics. His handling of Mohammad Ali Jinnah
and Muslim league is a testimony in this regard. He was impudent. That
he showed favouritism to Nehru over Sardar Vallabhai Patel over the
President-ship of Indian National Congress (INC) is a verity and that
it cost the nation dearly, too, is a reality. We have an undisclosed
belief in India; we all believe that when a man is declared ‘Great’ he
can do no wrong! We personate such men with perfection. This is
certainly a matter of lugubriousness as it stands against the
fundamentals of sapience.
It
should certainly baffle anyone as to why it be that these very Indian
politicians, who retort to so many brutal modes to triumph in
elections, to traduce their antagonists and suppress their critics go
‘Gandhian’ versus a grievous neighbouring country. Why this
‘non-violence’ attitude? Why don’t they inverse their approach and
show their ‘Gandhigiri’ to their political opponents and depict their
vandalism with their nation’s adversary? At least, can’t they do
anything more than offering lip service of ‘criticism’, ‘condemnation’
and ‘warnings’ against an ever shrewd neighbour?
Recently, after the Mumbai blasts when Mumbaikars took to the streets
in protest against the blasts, I was feeling a strange emotion. I was
unsure as to whether should I cry or laugh. After all what did they
achieve by lighting those candles? Yes, we do need to pray for the
departed souls but what about the security of the living souls? No one
pays any heed. After the blasts a great number of people took to
abusing the politicos. The blame was according to me utterly unjust.
Strange, but true, not a word was spoken against those terrorists. It
was trying to appear as if it were politicians who had planted those
bombs!
This was all to get publicity. Does anyone in India understand the
seriousness of Islamic terrorism? Does anyone knows that those Arabs
flush with petro-dollars are investing profusely into those thousands
of Madrassas bustling amidst our cities and towns in every major city
polluting young minds with ideas of insanity? Do they understand how
important it is take a strong action against them? And even if they
come to know, I am convinced, they would prefer to keep mum, sit in
the comforts of their home and if another blasts happen they come in
open in ‘strong criticism’ against the government (not terrorists, or
Pakistan – mind you) and go back until the next blasts take place.
The legacy of Mahatma Gandhi is for us not a source of inspiration.
From it we find rationales to support our awry ideology.
If
we are weak we are sure to be invaded, assaulted and persecuted.
History of our land starting from the invasion of Mohammad Ghazni in
1000 AD to onslaught of China in 60’s is supportive of this fact. We
are always betrayed by these nincompoops because we haven’t dealt them
with an iron fist. We have well over a billion population but we have
not started to think and work as a nation of billion people – which is
a deeply saddening part.
We
certainly need Mahatma Gandhi’s ideas and ideals, but when it comes to
politics let’s follow Kautilya. By shouting against our own people and
by completely not understanding our true opponent we are making
ourselves a weak and fragile nation. We have every reason to be
impregnable, to be challenging and even lead the world. But by
applying our right ideology at the wrong place we are sure to weaken
our resolve and kill our prospect of becoming a happy, prosperous and
formidable nation.
-
Read More &
Post Your Comments
The Kautilya Perspective
Beint Anti Muslim
By U. Mahesh Prabhu |
'I wonder why you
write such a column replete with hate and vengeance' alleged a
protagonist, who calls himself as a 'secularist', on reading my
previous columns. But when I asked him to aid me in finding those
words of 'hate and vengeance' he wasted no time to enjoin 'I don't
have time for that'! When an allegation is levelled, one cannot but
seek elucidation. Not even once have those allegers took some time to
warrant those allegations.
-
Read More &
Post Your Comments
SUBSCRIBE
COLUMNIST FEEDS
This
is Columnist's Own Space - Own Voice! The views expressed in these Blog Posts are of the
Author. www.mjakbar.org is not responsible for
Write-ups on this page.
The columnist articles are Copyright and the respective Author
should be contacted for permission whatsover. |
|
HAVE YOUR SAY! POSTED
ON YOUR BLOG ON MJ? Send your
Link to be posted ON Blogroll here.
|
WRITE FOR MJA:
Global Issues, Politics and Current Affairs.
BE A COLUMNIST ON
MJA
Weekly Columnists
Space -
Send your Sample Article in
500-700 words with your profile and url, if any. (No Attachments,
please)
Subscribe Feeds of M J Akbar's
Bylines

Recent Pic of U
Mahesh Prabhu with M J Akbar